{ 24 comments… read them below or add one }

Mandy Kilinskis

As a fairly new Google+ user, I have to admit, I’m not yet impressed. The place has potential, but there’s no way it will be taking down Facebook or Twitter any time soon.

Reply

JPorretto

I’ll +1 that.

Reply

LK

I’ll + 2 that.

Reply

amy

I know yesterday we were discussing Google and how they seem to try something to fit into every market. Sometimes it’s successful (search engine, picture sharing, email service), and sometimes it’s not. I commend their effort to try something new, but just taking the most popular features from other social networking sites isn’t anything new or creative. It’s convenient for the user, but not much else.

Reply

Peemo

Another social network I’ll be chastised for avoiding.

These blogs keep reminding me how old and crotchety I’ve become.

Reply

amy

Aww, hang in there :) Being old and crotchety has its advantages too

Reply

JPorretto

After my short time on Google+, I’d say the whole experience is just…. dry. You add someone to a circle and then…. what exactly? There’s just really not much to do that isn’t done (better) somewhere else.

Though the instant updating of comments is pretty nifty. I’ll give it that.

Reply

amy

There are somethings that are quite spiffy on it. I use Picasa to touch up photos so it’s really nice that I can go into my albums already and pick a picture instead of having to save it and then load it onto Facebook.

On the down side, Facebook has conditioned me to be able to simply press “Enter” to post a status, link, picture, etc and with Google+ you have to manually press “Share”. A minor problem, but kinda inconvenient.

Reply

Amanda

Great post Amy! =) This is the best set of details I’ve heard about Google+ to date…thank you for filling us all in!

I’d say that I’m a below average social networking user. I deleted my MySpace page a long while ago, quit using Twitter after about 2 days, and use Facebook fairly often–every other day or so- (it’s the only one I see a point in using) and that’s it, I haven’t joined any other sites. I enjoy Facebook, and hope it stays how it is for a long time, and if it does, I don’t think I’ll have a need to use more sites. Google+ doesn’t sound super impressive to me–but I think it has a pretty good chance of catching on. The +1 feature sounds neat, and with the huge love of the Like Button, I think people will start loving the +1 soon enough too, that is once they start letting people join “normally”–I don’t think people will be a big fan of this invite stuff.

Reply

Mandy Kilinskis

Amanda, the almost 5 million people already on Google+ I think will disagree.

http://www.zdnet.com/blog/networking/how-many-millions-of-people-are-already-using-google-plus/1237

Reply

amy

I totally agree with this blog’s suggestion that Google is “creating an artificial shortage of invites for hype”. Facebook was hugely popular when it was strictly open to college students and that’s part of the reason it has maybe become so huge today. People love that exclusive feeling that inviting creates.

I wonder how long the invite stage will last, just until testing is done or afterward too?

Reply

Amanda

Yeah–that’s more of how i meant it when I said people won’t like the invite stuff…I meant for the long term. But who knows!? People are crazy, lol. =) If it weren’t for the invite thing, I might join and check it out…but needing an invite makes me care less about joining. Facebook satisfies my online social needs.

Reply

Amanda

5 million is a great start–it will be interesting to see if this site sticks around–we all saw what happened with MySpace.

Reply

LK

I haven’t been too impressed since joining Google + either..
It currently appears to be a downgrade from Facebook and I feel like all the “features” they are saying Google + can do, that Facebook can essentially do too.
Unless Google + pulls something big out, and lets more people join (really.. I think I only have like 8 people in my “circles”) then I have no desire to start using Google + regularly.

Good post though!! :)

Reply

amy

I’m with you too! It’s so plain looking, but not simple like Facebook, just boring. I’m not sure if I’ll check it regularly like I do Twitter and Facebook, especially if it doesn’t catch on. I only have 6 or 7 people in my circles and I see them daily so I can pretty much be kept up to date by simply talking to them.

Reply

Vern-Matic

I recently noticed that while waiting for an invite into Google+ I now look down on myself the same way I used to look down on Apple consumers that wait in line for hours awaiting the new Apple “thing”.

Reply

amy

Nothing wrong with being an early adopter. At least you don’t have to wait outside during a rainstorm or in negative thirty degree temps ;)

Reply

Joseph Giorgi

I haven’t explored Google+ for myself, but given everything that I’ve heard and read, I’m just going to wait this one out. We’ll find out relatively soon whether this new platform can live up to all the hype it’s generated over the past couple weeks.

Seems that Google is banking on “Circles” being a major hit with casual users, but as Lauren pointed out, that feature doesn’t amount to much if no one is even there to use it. I’m curious to find out how adamant the public will be about jumping into a new social network when they’ve already spent several years becoming fluent with Facebook.

I can see Google+ taking off, but not for a little while. It’s going to take some time. Of course, Google has nothing but time.. and power… and resources. They should be able to give their new platform the marketing push it needs.

Excellent post, Amy! :)

Reply

amy

Thanks Joe :) You’re quite right about becoming fluent in Facebook, since it has been apart of our lives for at least five years (they removed their student email requirement in ’06) and we’ve sat through several changes during that time. It’ll be interesting to see if people are willing to put up with another social network when they do updates and changes.

Very true about their available resources, both in tangible and intangible assets. If the public wants to see Google+ work, I’m sure they’ll do whatever it takes to make it successful.

Reply

Karla Campos

Hi Amy, I am shocked to hear that people are selling invites on Ebay! I have been inviting bloggers to join me because Google + is a great way to unite with people in your same niche. I like the hangout feature because you can video chat with up to 10 people at one time, which I think is great for businesses. If anyone wants a free invite please ask on my facebook page at http://www.facebook.com/giglogo : )

Reply

amy

Hey Karla! Thanks for the comment :)

When I came across people selling invites my jaw literally dropped to the floor! I knew you could sell anything on it, but that shocked me.

Reply

Kyle

I haven’t been staying up to date on the latest Google+ news at all so thanks for the introduction, Amy! I might try it out once it goes public, but for now I’m content with occasionally checking my Facebook. I’m not a huge fan of social network sites so having one account is plenty for me.

I guess it really depends how it takes off. As is the case with all of these social networks, time will only tell.

Reply

amy

Happy to help Kyle :)

I think a lot of people are in the same boat with you, checking up and updating Facebook is enough for most people. It’ll be interesting to see what comes about from the testing phase.

Reply

Amanda

Turns out you can +1 things without using the actual Google+ site. As long as you have a Gmail account, you can +1 your little hearts out. Needless to say, I’m loving being able to +1 without the invite deal. Love it! =)

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: